Vancouver Criminal Law


Vancouver: 604 685 8889
Richmond: 604 370 3050
Surrey: 604 593 8580
Victoria: 250 384 0100
Nanaimo: 250 754 9558
Kelowna: 250 860 2766
Kamloops: 250 372 3448
Fort McMurray: 780 750 7588
Prince George: 250 564 8835



Copyright 2018 Acumen Law Corporation.
All Rights Reserved.

Call 24 Hrs

604 685 8889

Call Us For Free Consultation




The BC Supreme Court calls it like it is

The BC Supreme Court calls it like it is

Court ruling

October 2, 2014 UPDATE: The Supreme Court of Canada reversed the decision of the BC Court of Appeal, essentially reinstating the trial judge’s ruling. As we originally said, the BC Supreme Court judge called it like it is.

The decision can be found here:


The newspaper headline will talk about the BC Supreme Court finding that court fees are unconstitutional. The decision is 178 pages long, and we noticed that the Court’s website is down, so for the ease of our readers we’ve posted the entire judgment here (Vilardell v. Dunham).

The Court covers many of the problems we’ve discussed on our Vancouver Criminal Law blog. We like the way that these issues are expressed in the judgment. We will give a full analysis in the coming days. For now, here is a quote worth repeating.

[427] The Attorney General has a further role to play in explaining the function of the courts to government. The preservation of the core values of our Constitution including inclusiveness, equality and citizen participation are entrusted to the Attorney General as much as they are to the courts. In fact, given the passive institutional nature of the courts, the Attorney General holds the office best able to actively promote these values. It is therefore a matter of serious concern that the Attorney General has come to this Court with a submission that appears so dismissive of these fundamental aspects of our system of government.

As we have said numerous times, we do not think that the Attorney General understands her role.

UPDATE: If you go to the page listing Ministers in the BC Government, and try to follow the link to the biography of the Attorney General you will note that right now a blank page opens.

Given this Court decision, her position as AG seems untenable. This may be an indication that she is being dumped in a long-overdue cabinet shuffle.

The BC Supreme Court calls it like it is was last modified: by

No Comments

Leave a Comment