Vancouver Criminal Law

OUR LOCATIONS:

Vancouver: 604 685 8889
Richmond: 604 370 3050
Surrey: 604 593 8580
Victoria: 250 384 0100
Kelowna: 250 860 2766
Fort McMurray: 780 750 7588

Facebook

Twitter

Copyright 2016 Acumen Law Corporation.
All Rights Reserved.

Call 24 Hrs

604 685 8889

Call Us For Free Consultation

Facebook

Twitter

Search
Locations
 

Blog

Rule of Law

Montesquieu gave definition to the Rule of Law and the division of powers

There is a strange tension in British Columbia at the moment between the Government and the courts. As a result, the chief judges from each level of court in B.C. signed a statement about judicial independence and the rule of law which is re-published here. This is a highly unusual step. Typically, the judges in our province can rely on lawyers to speak up in defence of the courts. Many lawyers have done just that in the last few years, ourselves included. The problem in this case is that the criticism is coming from the Government. And this poses a threat...

Continue reading

The Legend of the Second ASD Sample

The second ASD sample is as rare as a unicorn if they police don't have a second breathalyzer handy.

Earlier in the week we mentioned that the police rarely correctly follow the second sample requirements. Whether it is a Warn range Immediate Roadside Prohibition (IRP) or a now de facto - defunct 90-day IRP for blowing Fail, the police often screw this up. We received emails prodding us for more information and from people who were never our clients with their stories. So we thought we would explain more of the background What we found was you are more likely to be offered a second ASD sample during an IRP investigation if you are at a roadblock. If you were simply...

Continue reading

Bad News in the Mail

Attractive Vancouver woman gets a letter from ICBC with details about her driving prohibition

If you just received an Administrative Driving Prohibition (ADP), a 30-day Immediate Roadside Prohibition (IRP) or a 90-day IRP, a nasty letter is coming your way. The IRP or ADP Notice of Prohibition does not explain the misery that is about to befall you. Only after the 7-day appeal period has expired will you receive the unexpected and unpleasant missive from the Superintendent of Motor Vehicles telling you that you must now complete the Responsible Drivers Program (RDP) and drive with an Interlock for at least a year (with GPS monitoring your every move). It is dirty that you do not get...

Continue reading

Peculiarities of the IRP Legal Limbo

Although the IRP law with respect to 90-day prohibitions for Fail was found to be unconstitutional, the law was left on the books until June. The Government argued that it was necessary to save lives. And the Court more or less accepted that argument. But the police stopped applying the IRP law, probably because they were uncomfortable using an unconstitutional law which might open them to liability. And it clearly was not needed to save lives because the drinking and driving stats in the last few months are the lowest in years. So we are in legal limbo. The law is...

Continue reading

What Damage Did You Suffer from Your IRP?

When the BC Supreme Court ruled on November 30, 2011 that the 90-day Immediate Roadside Prohibition scheme for Fail blows violates the Charter, many people contacted us looking for compensation for their loss. We asked everyone to sit tight because despite the ruling, we know the Government will do everything it can to avoid writing cheques. In the weeks that followed we learned that the Government intended to ask the Court to suspend the declaration that the law was invalid. Our view was that an unlawful law remaining in place would not be applied because it opened up the police to...

Continue reading

Roadside Breath Tests Tainted by Police Negligence

a

One of our lawyers is a member of the California DUI Lawyer's Association, so we follow the goings on with drinking/driving law in the Golden State. The authorities there are now dealing with revelations of roadside breath tests tainted by improper calibration. Although much of the law is different, there are a few similarities. There is a movement to deciding matters with government tribunals. And there are always problems with breath-testing machines. Most recently the defence lawyers in San Fransisco revealed that the police had not been calibrating their Alco-Sensor IV roadside breath testers. This is a problem our office has...

Continue reading

Tribunalization – Ousting the Courts

The BC Government wants to take matters from the court and give them to tribunals

The SPCA is angry at the Government. Their particular concern is that the Government is establishing a tribunal to deal with allegations under the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, rather than having the matters dealt with in court. You can read their entire statement here, but this is an important excerpt: The BC SPCA says the proposed changes to the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, introduced by the government today in Bill 24, have no benefits for animals in B.C. “We are very disappointed to see these amendments, which we believe will make it more difficult for the BC SPCA...

Continue reading

Booze and Privatization

In the 2012 budget announcement Finance Minister Kevin Falcon indicated that the Government would privatize the liquor distribution warehouses in BC. The Government can thereby receive a one-time windfall in the sale of these assets and it no longer needs to manage the distribution of liquor to stores in BC. Whether you agree with this is largely an issue of ideology. It appears the process may be tainted by virtue of the involvement of lobbyists who donated money toward the Premier's campaign to lead the BCLiberal Party. You can read about that here. We suspect that this is the first step to...

Continue reading

Kill the Breathalyzer

Kill the breathalyzer in BC

The Alco-Sensor IV, which is the roadside breathalyzer that we use in BC, is a sturdy, nicely-designed device that is well suited for its purpose, i.e. to screen drivers to determine who should be subject to breath tests on an evidentiary breath tester. One of the reasons that they should never be used to justify punishing people is that they tend to get dropped regularly. The usual mistake is to leave it on the roof or trunk lid of a police cruiser. When the officer hears it tumble off the car, there is a quick stop to retrieve the device. If...

Continue reading

You Should Now Have Your License Back

If you received a 90-day IRP for blowing Fail, then there is no reason for you not to have your license back pending the outcome of the lead case that is still before the Court. The BC Government is planning to introduce legislation soon to address the Court decision that ruled that the IRP scheme violates the Charter of Rights. We should see what they have up their sleeve in the next few weeks. But as it stands, the entire case appears headed to the Court of Appeal so it may take months for this to be sorted out. In the meantime,...

Continue reading